Puzzlebox Press
PO Box 765       Elkhorn, WI 53121      Phone   262-723-7750

Home

News & Reviews

How to Order

Terms & Conditions

Special Displays

Forthcoming

Food for Thought

About

Send a Message

 

Preview books at: http://books.google.com

 

 

from Chapter 7          Schism

The Volunteers wanted more than anything to go home, but after Tom read a batch of U.S. newspapers in late October, he said, “near as I can see, our chance is good for staying here all winter.” That was not a happy prospect. Morale  was low. Volunteers were angry at being kept in service after the peace protocol ended the fighting, which nominally marked the end of their military obligations.[i] Before the end of the year, Otis would send Washington more than 400 requests for discharge by Volunteers asserting their legal right to be discharged.[ii] An indication of their sour mood was the response to a solicitation for re-enlistment. Volunteers were promised $500 in travel and transportation pay at the end of another year’s service. It appears not a single man in the regiment took the offer. John quotes one as saying, “We are 10,000 miles from the place we did our volunteering.”

Discouraged and resentful, some Volunteers became sloppy soldiers. At a regimental inspection, Tom said Lt. Col. Treumann “found occasion to call quite a few of us down for not shaving, etc.” Others were wistful that a few lucky ones were returning home because of illness. By year’s end, eight from the 1st North Dakota would leave for the States, discharged for disability.[iii] Tom’s company wagoner was a different matter; Corp. Fred Mullen  (one of three Mullens in Company I) was discharged by order and was sent home because of his rheumatism. Tom was impressed with the man’s financial good fortune. He said Mullen:

got $508.24. It will cost him about $30.00 for board from here to Frisco so he will be able to reach home with $400.00 in his pocket after 8 months service.

Also leaving the Philippines was part of the Nebraska Volunteer regiment and the Astor Battery, which turned its 3-inch Hotchkiss mountain guns over to the 18th U.S. Artillery. Seeing off the Astor men he had hoped to join, John regretfully mused – if only he had made his request for transfer sooner, he would be leaving with them. Those going home left hundreds like John who wished they were going also.[iv]

The rain did not help morale. Tom stood guard November 5 where there was “no shelter and it rained more or less.” On patrol near Blockhouse #14 a few days later, he said, “It is raining all the time so it is rather slushy.” On November 12, he said it had “rained steady for 3 days, and we have had no drills and all roll calls inside.” Next day, he said, “It rains still....” On November 15, a Dress Parade was called off because “the parade ground was too damp.” Both weather and grounds at last permitted the delayed Dress Parade on November 20, but a week later at General Inspection, it rained so hard “we looked like a lot of drowned rats.” Two days later, Tom stood guard on still another “disagreeable day, a continual drizzle of rain right along.”


[i] “Nominally” is the operative word. Their military obligation would end only after the peace treaty was ratified and signed by the President, legally bringing an end to the state of hostilities. 

[ii] U.S. Serial 3902, p. 44.

[iii] Those discharged were: Privates Philip Dawson, Edward Fay, and Louis Swett  of Company A; Pvt. James Hall, of Company K; Capt. Frederick Keye and Pvt. John McConnel of Company B; Corp. Daniel Wallace and Lt. Fred Conklin  of Company H. Tom’s notebook says Pvt. John C. Leathert of Company I, who was left at Honolulu to recover from illness, had also received his discharge. Cooper and Smith (p. 62) err in saying that Conklin received his discharge from Company B. From Jamestown, Conklin enlisted in Fargo’s Company  B, but on October 22 transferred to Jamestown’s Company H and was discharged from that company.

[iv] A. B. Feuer (America at War: The Philippines, 1898-1913) errs in saying the Astor Battery “steamed into New York harbor on 22 January 1899.” The Battery disembarked at Pier 7 in San Francisco and traveled by train across the U.S.

Click to Order

 

Copyright © 2005 Puzzlebox Press
Last modified: 12/28/10